November 19, 2026·40 min read

Valvoline (VVV), Financial Analysis

Insights derived from analysing SEC filings. Independent analysis, not a publication of the SEC.

System wide store sales FY2026
$4.07bn
+17.8% year on year (FY2025 $3.45bn); SSS +7.9%
Net revenues FY2026
$2.06bn
+20.7% year on year (FY2025 $1.71bn); Q4 $554m, +22.1%
Operating margin FY2026 (GAAP)
14.0%
(8.8 pts) year on year (FY2025 22.8%); adjusted EBITDA $557m
Key findings
  • Q4 FY2026 (quarter to 30 Sep 2026) net revenues $554m, +22.1%; FY2026 net revenues $2.06bn, +20.7%. System wide store sales, incl. franchisees, $4.07bn, +17.8%; system wide same store sales (SSS) +7.9% for the year and +9.4% in Q4, the highest quarter of the last eight.
  • Store count 2,517 at 30 Sep 2026, +337 or +15.5% in FY2026: 1,265 company operated (+249) and 1,252 franchised (+88). Breeze Autocare, bought on 1 Dec 2025 for $637.4m in cash, added 204 stores, of which 45 were sold the same day under an FTC order; goodwill $524.3m.
  • Margins fell on a GAAP basis: gross margin 37.3% against 38.5% (Q4 35.3% against 39.1%), operating margin 14.0% against 22.8%. FY2026 carries a $57.9m loss on the FTC required divestiture and $25.8m of legacy costs, while FY2025 had a $74.3m refranchising gain. Income from continuing operations $87.9m, (59.1%); EPS $0.69 against $1.67; adjusted EPS (non GAAP) $1.76, +10.7%.
  • Debt rose to $1.61bn from $1.07bn to fund Breeze; net debt $1.45bn is 2.6x adjusted EBITDA of $557m (report calculation) against the 1.5x to 2.5x target. Free cash flow $204m against $48m; no repurchases in FY2026; the authorization was raised to $500m in the Q4 release. Proceeds of the $600m of 6.125% notes due 2034 went to repay the term loan A in full and part of the term loan B.
  • FY2027 outlook (19 Nov 2026): net revenues $2.25bn to $2.35bn (+9% to +14%), SSS +5% to 7%, 190 to 220 store additions, adjusted EBITDA $595m to $625m and adjusted EPS $1.85 to $2.05; the outlook assumes no change in the supply environment, with stable availability and continued elevated product costs. FY2026 guidance was raised in May and Aug 2026.
  • Shares closed at $33.37 on 18 Nov 2026, 48.4x FY2026 GAAP EPS, 19.0x adjusted EPS and 17.1x the FY2027 adjusted EPS midpoint. Peers: Take 5 SSS +4.9% (Q3 2026, preliminary), Monro comparable sales (1.8%) (Sep 2026 quarter). Report scenarios (own assumptions) for end FY2029: base $41.35, best $63.03, worst $15.75.

Figures are read from the filings of Valvoline Inc. (central index key 1674910): the Q4 and FY2026 results release (8-K Ex 99.1 of 19 Nov 2026), the Forms 10-Q for Q1 to Q3 FY2026, the Forms 10-K for FY2024 and FY2025, the Forms 8-K with all their exhibits, incl. the quarterly results releases with every guidance revision, the Breeze Autocare closing filing, the investor update presentation of 11 Dec 2025, the credit agreement amendments and the 2034 notes indenture, the Item 5.02 officer and director filings and the Item 5.07 vote results, the 2026 proxy statement (DEF 14A of 19 Dec 2025), Schedules 13G, Forms 4, and the filings of Monro, Driven Brands and Mister Car Wash. The FY2026 Form 10-K was not on EDGAR on 19 Nov 2026, so FY2026 figures come from the release and the FY2026 revenue split by service, 10-K risk factors and Breeze final accounting await it. Valvoline files no separate CFO commentary; management statements come from the 8-K exhibits. Earnings call statements are not used. Share price $33.37 is the regular session close of 18 Nov 2026, before the release of 19 Nov 2026. Accession numbers appear in the Sources appendix.

1 Revenue & Business Model

  • Storyline: Valvoline runs and franchises quick lube service centers (Valvoline Instant Oil Change, Great Canadian Oil Change and, since Dec 2025, Oil Changers) in the US and Canada; FY2026 net revenues rose +21% as SSS and the Breeze stores both added sales, while GAAP profit fell on acquisition, divestiture and financing costs. Chapter 2 covers same store sales, chapter 3 network growth and the Breeze acquisition, chapter 4 the franchise system, each with industry change and competitors from their filings.
  • Revenue model: net revenues are sales at company operated stores plus royalties and fees from franchised and Express Care stores; franchised store sales ($2.22bn in FY2026) are not consolidated. FY2025 split (10-K): oil change services $1.25bn (72.9%), non oil change services $368m (21.5%), franchise fees and other $95m.
  • 9M FY2026 (10-Q): oil change services $1.11bn, +21.9%; non oil change services $321m, +16.7%; franchise fees and other $78m, +12.0%. Breeze contributed $117.1m of revenue and $13.1m of net income from 1 Dec 2025 to 30 Jun 2026.
  • Scale and history: continuing operations since the sale of Global Products to Aramco in Mar 2023; net revenues grew from $1.24bn in FY2022, a 13.7% annual rate. FY2026 was the 20th consecutive year of system wide SSS growth; US customers were 96.9% of FY2025 net revenues.
  • Supply: substantially all lubricant is bought from VGO (Valvoline Global Operations, owned by Aramco) under a long term supply agreement (10-K FY2025).
Figure 1.1 Net revenues and operating margin, FY2022 to FY2026 (continuing operations)
Figure 1.2 Net revenues by service, FY2023 to FY2025 ($bn)
Table 1.1 Store sales and store counts, Q4 and full year
MeasureQ4 FY2025Q4 FY2026ChangeFY2025FY2026Change
System wide store sales ($m)918.41,103.4+20.1%3,453.84,067.5+17.8%
Company operated store sales ($m)399.0507.2+27.1%1,499.61,847.2+23.2%
Franchised store sales ($m)519.4596.2+14.8%1,954.22,220.3+13.6%
System wide SSS growth (%)6.09.4+3.4 pts6.17.9+1.8 pts
Company operated stores1,0161,265+249
Franchised stores1,1641,252+88
System wide stores2,1802,517+337
Source: 8-K Ex 99.1 of 19 Nov 2026, Table 4. Store sales and SSS include franchisees, which Valvoline does not consolidate. From FY2026 SSS includes mobile service net revenues in markets that use store marketing.
Table 1.2 Net revenues by service, Q3 and nine months ($m)
ServiceQ3 FY2025Q3 FY2026Q3 growth9M FY20259M FY20269M growthFY2025
Oil change services319.3405.4+27.0%912.01,111.5+21.9%1,247.3
Non oil change services93.9110.0+17.1%275.2321.1+16.7%368.4
Franchise fees and other25.829.2+13.2%69.377.6+12.0%94.6
Net revenues439.0544.6+24.1%1,256.51,510.2+20.2%1,710.3
Source: 10-Q Q3 FY2026 and 10-K FY2025 revenue disaggregation (XBRL). The FY2026 split will be in the FY2026 10-K.

2 Same Store Sales: Ticket, Pricing and Non Oil Change Services

  • System wide SSS +7.9% in FY2026 against +6.1% in FY2025; by quarter +5.8%, +8.2%, +8.0% and +9.4%. System wide store sales grew +17.8%, the difference coming from new and acquired stores.
  • Drivers named in the 10-Q Q3 FY2026: higher average ticket from pricing actions, premiumization and non oil change service penetration, with modest growth in transactions. 9M FY2026 non oil change revenue rose +16.7% and oil change revenue +21.9%.
  • Definition change: from FY2026 SSS includes mobile service net revenues in markets that use store marketing channels; SSS covers US VIOC stores open at least 12 full months.
  • Outlook: SSS +5% to 7% for FY2027 against the investor update range of +3% to 5% a year for 2026 to 2028.
Figure 2.1 Same store sales and store sales growth by quarter

How quick lube and car service demand is changing and how competitors compare

  • Lubricant costs (10-Q Q3 FY2026): supply conditions for certain lubricant products tightened in the Jun 2026 quarter; Valvoline used pricing actions and procurement to hold availability, and states costs are expected to stay elevated in the near term.
  • Supply dependence (10-K FY2025): substantially all lubricant is bought from VGO, the former Global Products business sold to Aramco in Mar 2023, under a long term supply agreement.
  • Car parc (investor update, 11 Dec 2025): average vehicle age 11.5 years in 2015, 12.8 years in 2025 and 13.3 years projected for 2028; Valvoline cites full synthetic mix and vehicle complexity as ticket drivers.
  • Full service repair (Monro 8-K, 29 Oct 2026): Monro comparable store sales fell 1.8% in the Sep 2026 quarter, with batteries +8% and maintenance +3% while tires and brakes fell 4%; Monro cites lower traffic and trade down in tires.
  • Quick lube peer (Driven Brands 8-K, 3 Nov 2026): preliminary Take 5 same store sales +4.9% in Q3 2026, the 25th consecutive quarter of growth; full year Take 5 guide 3.5% to 4.0%, with pressure on lower income consumers named.
Figure 2.2 Same store sales growth by company
Table 2.1 Same store sales against competitors, latest filed quarters
Company and measurePeriodValueDetail
Valvoline system wide SSSQ4 FY2026 (Sep 2026 quarter)+9.4%FY2026 +7.9%; system wide store sales +20.1%
Valvoline system wide SSSQ3 FY2026 (Jun 2026 quarter)+8.0%pricing actions in the quarter (10-Q)
Driven Brands, Take 5 SSSQ3 2026 (Sep 2026 quarter), preliminary+4.9%25th consecutive quarter of growth; 2026 guide 3.5% to 4.0%
Driven Brands, Take 5 SSSQ2 2026 (Jun 2026 quarter)+3.6%Take 5 revenue $334.8m; segment adjusted EBITDA $114.9m
Driven Brands, all brands SSSQ3 2026 (Sep 2026 quarter), preliminary+2.0%statements under Item 4.02 non reliance
Mister Car Wash comparable store salesQ1 2026 (Mar 2026 quarter)+3.9%net revenues $277.9m, +6.2%; last quarter filed before going private
Monro comparable store salesQ2 FY2027 (Sep 2026 quarter)(1.8%)batteries +8%, maintenance +3%, tires and brakes (4%)
Company definitions of same store and comparable store sales differ. Driven Brands statements are under Item 4.02 non reliance; Take 5 Q3 2026 data are preliminary.

3 Network Growth: Breeze Autocare and New Stores

  • 2,517 stores at 30 Sep 2026, +337 in FY2026: company opened 75, acquired 228 (incl. 210 in Q1 with Breeze), divested 45 under the FTC order; franchisees opened 87; 8 closures.
  • Breeze Autocare (filed): 204 stores under the Oil Changers brand in California, Texas and the Midwest; cash consideration $637.4m; 45 stores sold to Main Street Auto Express Oil; revenue $50.8m and net income $5.8m in the Jun 2026 quarter. The investor update gave average unit volume of $1.1m at acquisition with a target of about $1.2m, and a post synergy multiple of about 7.0x.
  • Organic openings: 162 stores opened in FY2026 (75 company, 87 franchise), 54 in Q4 (61 store additions incl. 7 acquired). Growth capex $129.0m in 9M FY2026; the investor update targets a new store cost of about $2.0m by 2028 from about $2.3m.
  • Outlook: 190 to 220 system wide store additions in FY2027; more than 2,900 stores by 2028 and about 3,500 longer term (investor update).
Figure 3.1 System wide stores by quarter
Figure 3.2 Store count bridge FY2026

How the store landscape is changing and how competitors compare

  • Consolidation: Valvoline closed Breeze Autocare (204 stores) on 1 Dec 2025 and sold 45 of them under an FTC order; Mister Car Wash was taken private by Leonard Green & Partners at $7.00 per share on 19 May 2026 (8-K Item 2.01).
  • Store footprint (investor update): Valvoline put its share of the oil change market at about 6% in 2025 against about 5% in 2022, with a target of 7% to 8% by 2028 and more than 2,900 stores.
  • Take 5 growth (Driven Brands 8-K, 6 Aug 2026): 1,421 Take 5 stores at 27 Jun 2026 against 1,244 a year earlier; 27 net new units in Q3 2026 (preliminary) and 155+ net new units guided for 2026.
  • Full service contraction (Monro 10-K FY2026 and 8-K): Monro closed 145 underperforming stores in Q1 FY2026 and ended Sep 2026 with 1,114 company stores and 47 franchised.
  • Build cost (investor update): Valvoline new store cost about $2.7m in 2022 and about $2.3m in 2025, with a $2.0m target for 2028.
Table 3.1 Store networks against competitors, latest filed dates
Company and measurePeriodValueDetail
Valvoline system wide30 Sep 20262,517+337 in FY2026 (+15.5%); company 1,265, franchised 1,252
Driven Brands, Take 527 Jun 20261,421against 1,244 a year earlier (+14.2%); 27 net new units in Q3 2026 (preliminary)
Monro26 Sep 20261,1611,114 company and 47 franchised; 145 stores closed in Q1 FY2026
Mister Car Wash31 Mar 2026549against 518 a year earlier (+6.0%); taken private 19 May 2026
Store counts as filed by each company; Monro counts tire and repair stores, Mister Car Wash car wash locations.

4 Franchise System: Store Sales, Fees and Conversions

  • Franchised store sales $2.22bn in FY2026, +13.6%, against company operated store sales $1.85bn, +23.2%; franchised stores made 54.6% of system wide store sales against 56.6%, as Breeze added company stores.
  • Franchise fees and other revenue $77.6m in 9M FY2026, +12.0%; 5.1% of net revenues. Prices of products Valvoline sells to independent operators generally move with published base oil indices (10-K FY2025).
  • Conversions: 10 company stores sold to a franchisee in Q1 FY2026 for a $14.3m gain and 4 converted back in Q2; in Q1 FY2025 39 stores were refranchised for a $74.3m gain. Franchised share of stores 49.7% against 53.4%.
  • Franchisee returns (investor update): initial investment about $2.0m, net sales at maturity above $1.8m and four wall EBITDA margins above 25%; franchisees to make up 50% to 60% of new store additions.
Figure 4.1 System wide store sales by quarter, company and franchised

How franchising is changing and how competitors compare

  • Franchise mix target (investor update): franchisees to deliver 50% to 60% of new store additions over 2026 to 2028; the margin roadmap shows the franchise mix of new stores rising from 42% in 2025 to about 60% in 2028 (E).
  • Franchisee economics (investor update): initial investment about $2.0m, net sales at maturity above $1.8m and four wall EBITDA margins above 25%.
  • Take 5 mix (Driven Brands 8-K, 6 Aug 2026): 569 franchised and 852 company Take 5 stores at 27 Jun 2026; franchised Take 5 system sales $183m, +23% year on year.
  • Driven Brands reporting (8-K, 3 Nov 2026): non reliance on FY2023 to FY2025 and Q1, Q2 2026 statements; FDD delays constrain Franchise Brands openings until the restatement is complete.
  • Monro (8-K, 29 Oct 2026): 47 franchised locations against 1,114 company operated.
Figure 4.2 Franchised share of stores by company
Table 4.1 Franchise mix against competitors, latest filed quarters
Company and measurePeriodValueDetail
ValvolineQ4 FY202649.7%franchised store sales $596.2m in Q4, +14.8%; FY2026 $2.22bn, +13.6%
Driven Brands, Take 5Q2 2026 (Jun 2026 quarter)40.0%franchised Take 5 system sales $183.1m, +22.8%
MonroQ2 FY2027 (Sep 2026 quarter)4.0%47 franchised locations
Mister Car WashQ1 2026 (Mar 2026 quarter)0.0%all locations company operated; 2.5m Unlimited Wash Club members
Franchised share is franchised stores over total stores as filed.

5 Financial Analysis & Ratios

  • FY2026 net revenues $2.06bn, +20.7%; gross profit $770m, +16.9%, a 37.3% margin against 38.5%; operating income $289m, (26.0%), a 14.0% margin against 22.8%. Adjusted EBITDA (company measure) $557m, +19.3%, at 27.0% of adjusted net revenues against 27.3%.
  • Income from continuing operations $87.9m against $214.8m; diluted EPS $0.69 against $1.67; adjusted EPS $1.76, +10.7%. The effective tax rate rose to 45.7% from 26.5%: the divestiture loss gave no tax benefit and produced $6.3m of tax expense, and some Breeze transaction costs were not deductible (10-Q). Net interest and financing expense $113.5m against $74.0m.
  • Cash flow FY2026: operating cash flow from continuing operations $432m, +40.6%; capex $228m (11.0% of net revenues against 15.2%), of which maintenance $61.8m; free cash flow $204m (9.9% of net revenues). Acquisitions used $664m, mainly Breeze; $63.6m came from the sale of operations.
  • Balance sheet at 30 Sep 2026: cash $163m; total debt $1.61bn, all long term; net debt $1.45bn; goodwill and intangibles $1.29bn against $741m; stockholders' equity $427m. ROE 23.0% on average equity.
Table 5.1 Income statement, cash flow and balance sheet summary ($m unless stated)
Line itemFY2022FY2023FY2024FY2025FY2026
Revenue1,236.11,443.51,619.01,710.32,064.3
Gross profit476.4544.5618.8658.5770.0
Selling, general and administrative244.7264.5305.1339.5410.9
Operating income220.3247.2367.2389.9288.5
Net income109.4199.4214.5214.887.9
Diluted EPS ($)0.611.231.631.670.69
Operating cash flow134.4353.0282.9307.1431.7
Capital expenditure(132.0)(180.5)(224.4)(259.2)(228.0)
Free cash flow2.4172.558.547.9203.7
Stock based compensation14.412.212.010.511.1
Cash and investmentsn/a756.668.351.6163.0
Total debtn/a1,586.11,093.81,074.01,614.0
Total equity306.6203.2185.6338.5427.2
Fiscal years end 30 September. Continuing operations: the Global Products business sold in Mar 2023 is excluded. Net income lines show income from continuing operations. FY2025 SG&A and other income are as recast in the FY2026 release ($339.5m and $72.3m against $349.9m and $82.7m in the 10-K); operating income is unchanged. FY2022 balance sheet items other than equity are omitted (pre separation presentation). In the Q4 comparison table, Q4 operating cash flow and free cash flow are derived as full year less nine months (report calculation).
Figure 5.1 Quarterly revenue and margins
Table 5.2 What changed, Q4 FY2026 against Q4 FY2025
MetricQ4 FY2025Q4 FY2026Change
Revenue ($m)453.8554.122.1%
Gross profit ($m)177.5195.610.2%
Operating income ($m)84.572.0(14.8%)
Net income ($m)25.69.8(61.7%)
Diluted EPS ($)0.200.08(60.0%)
Operating cash flow ($m)127.1147.115.7%
Free cash flow ($m)28.291.4224.1%
Operating margin (%)18.613.0(5.6 pts)
Net margin (%)5.61.8(3.9 pts)
Table 5.3 Ratio analysis
RatioFY2022FY2023FY2024FY2025FY2026
Growth and margins
Revenue growth (%)n/a16.812.25.620.7
Gross margin (%)38.537.738.238.537.3
Operating margin (%)17.817.122.722.814.0
Net margin (%)8.913.813.212.64.3
FCF margin (%)0.212.03.62.89.9
Cost and investment intensity
SBC (%) revenue1.20.80.70.60.5
Capex (%) revenue10.712.513.915.211.0
Effective tax rate (%)24.115.724.426.545.7
Returns
ROE (%)35.778.2110.382.023.0
ROA (%)n/a6.98.18.42.8
ROIC (%)54.620.222.921.112.6
Asset turnover (x)n/a0.500.660.640.57
Liquidity and leverage
Current ratio (x)n/a2.590.720.700.90
Debt to equity (x)n/a7.815.893.173.78
Net cash ($bn)n/a(0.8)(1.0)(1.0)(1.5)
Efficiency and cash quality
Days sales outstandingn/a21191918
Inventory daysn/a14141515
FCF to net income (x)0.020.870.270.222.32
ROE uses average equity; FY2022 ROE uses year end equity and FY2022 ROIC omits debt and cash (no FY2022 balance sheet on a continuing basis), so both are not comparable with later years. FY2023 cash includes $347.5m of short term investments. FY2026 from the 8-K Ex 99.1 of 19 Nov 2026.
Figure 5.2 Margin profile
Figure 5.3 Operating cash flow, capital expenditure and free cash flow
Table 5.4 Valuation snapshot at $33.37 per share, close 18 Nov 2026
MeasureValue
Market cap ($bn)4.3
Enterprise value (net debt at 30 Sep 2026) ($bn)5.7
P/E on FY2026 GAAP EPS (x)48.4
P/E on FY2026 adjusted EPS (x)19.0
P/E on FY2027 adjusted EPS guidance midpoint (x)17.1
EV/Adjusted EBITDA FY2026 (x)10.2
EV/Sales FY2026 (x)2.8
FCF yield on FY2026 FCF (%)4.8

Cost structure and profitability

  • Cost of sales 64.7% of Q4 net revenues against 60.9%, and 62.7% for FY2026 against 61.5%; the 10-Q links lower margins to depreciation, occupancy and labor from new and acquired stores and, from the Jun 2026 quarter, higher lubricant costs.
  • SG&A $411m, +21.0%, 19.9% of net revenues against 19.9%; 9M FY2026 SG&A included $24.1m of acquisition and divestiture costs, mainly Breeze (10-Q). Q4 SG&A was 18.5% of net revenues against 20.4%.
  • Items between gross profit and operating income, FY2026: net legacy and separation related expenses $25.8m against $1.4m; other loss $44.8m (incl. the $57.9m divestiture loss and a $14.3m refranchising gain) against other income of $72.3m in FY2025.
  • Costs (net revenues less operating income) rose 30.5% in Q4 against net revenue growth of 22.1%; Q4 operating margin 13.0% against 18.6%.
Figure 5.4 Gross, adjusted EBITDA and operating margin by quarter
Table 5.5 Costs and profit as % of net revenues, last five quarters
LineQ4 FY2025Q1 FY2026Q2 FY2026Q3 FY2026Q4 FY2026
Cost of sales (% of net revenues)60.962.662.960.564.7
Selling, general and administrative (% of net revenues)20.423.119.618.918.5
Operating income (% of net revenues)18.64.017.120.613.0
Adjusted EBITDA (non GAAP) (% of net revenues)28.725.426.529.825.9
Income from continuing operations (% of net revenues)5.6(7.0)9.011.91.8
Table 5.6 Q4 FY2026 against Q4 FY2025 ($m)
LineQ4 FY2025Q4 FY2026Change
Net revenues453.8554.1100.3
Cost of sales(276.3)(358.5)(82.2)
Selling, general and administrative(92.7)(102.4)(9.7)
Net legacy and separation related0.2(19.6)(19.8)
Other (loss) income, net(0.5)(1.6)(1.1)
Operating income84.572.0(12.5)
Net pension and postretirement(26.3)(16.7)9.6
Net interest and financing(21.0)(32.4)(11.4)
Income tax(11.6)(13.1)(1.5)
Income from continuing operations25.69.8(15.8)
Source: 8-K Ex 99.1 statement of consolidated income; Q4 FY2025 as recast in the FY2026 release. Expenses shown as negatives.

Breeze Autocare purchase accounting

  • Purchase price allocation at 30 Jun 2026 (10-Q, incl. measurement period adjustments): goodwill is 82.3% of the consideration; the 45 stores sold on closing are carried as net assets held for sale of $90.0m, against which the $57.9m loss was booked. Fair values stay preliminary for up to one year from 1 Dec 2025.
Table 5.7 Breeze Autocare, assets acquired and liabilities assumed ($m)
LineValue
Cash consideration637.4
Goodwill (not tax deductible)524.3
Net assets held for sale (45 stores sold on 1 Dec 2025)90.0
Property, plant and equipment (incl. $45.1m finance lease assets)75.1
Operating lease assets less operating lease liabilities10.2
Customer relationships and trademarks19.0
Cash, receivables, inventories, other current assets26.1
Payables, accrued and other current liabilities(37.1)
Other noncurrent assets less liabilities(70.2)
Source: 10-Q Q3 FY2026 Note 2. The 8-K of 1 Dec 2025 stated a net purchase price of $593m before adjustments for store acquisitions, sale leasebacks and working capital.

Capital allocation and debt

  • Cash flow FY2026: operating cash flow $432m and net borrowings of $530m (incl. issuance costs) funded $664m of acquisitions and $228m of capex; cash rose $111.4m to $163m.
  • Debt structure after Aug 2026: $535m of 3.625% notes due 2031, $600m of 6.125% notes due 2034 and the remaining term loan B due 2032; term loan A repaid in full; revolver $600m. Total debt $1.61bn at 30 Sep 2026; net interest $32.4m in Q4 against $21.0m.
  • Leverage: net debt to adjusted EBITDA 2.6x at 30 Sep 2026 against 2.2x a year earlier (report calculation on filed figures); the investor update gave about 3.2x pro forma after Breeze and a target under 2.5x within 18 to 24 months. Repurchases were paused in FY2026; the authorization now stands at $500m.
Figure 5.5 Sources and uses of cash FY2026

6 MD&A & Management Commentary

Q4 FY2026 results release (8-K Ex 99.1, 19 Nov 2026)

  • Q4 FY2026: net revenues $554.1m, +22.1%; system wide store sales $1.10bn, +20.1%; SSS +9.4%; 61 store additions (33 company, 28 franchise).
  • Q4 margins: gross margin 35.3% against 39.1%; operating income $72.0m, (14.8%), after $19.6m of net legacy and separation related expenses (indemnity obligations to the former parent and legacy matters); adjusted EBITDA $143.6m, +10.4%, at 25.9% of adjusted net revenues against 28.7%.
  • Q4 below the line: net pension expense $16.7m (remeasurement) against $26.3m; net interest $32.4m against $21.0m; income from continuing operations $9.8m, (61.7%); EPS $0.08; adjusted EPS $0.42 against $0.45.
  • Cost environment (10-Q Q3 FY2026): lubricant supply tightened for certain products in the Jun 2026 quarter; Valvoline used pricing actions, procurement and operations to keep availability, and expected costs to stay elevated in the near term. Q3 SSS of 8.0% included pricing actions.
  • Earlier FY2026 quarters (8-K Ex 99.1): Q1 net revenues $462m, +11%, SSS +5.8%; Q2 $504m, +25%, SSS +8.2%; Q3 $545m, +24%, SSS +8.0%. Q1 included the $57.9m divestiture loss and a $14.3m gain on 10 stores sold to a franchisee.
  • FY2027 outlook: net revenues $2.25bn to $2.35bn (+9.0% to +13.8% on FY2026, report calculation); SSS +5% to 7%; 190 to 220 store additions; adjusted EBITDA $595m to $625m (+6.8% to +12.2%); adjusted EPS $1.85 to $2.05; capex $245m to $265m.
Table 6.1 FY2027 outlook as filed in the 8-K Ex 99.1 of 19 Nov 2026
ItemOutlookSource
System wide SSS growth5.0% to 7.0%8-K Ex 99.1, 19 Nov 2026
System wide store additions190 to 220same
Net revenues$2.25bn to $2.35bnsame
Adjusted EBITDA (non GAAP)$595m to $625msame
Adjusted EPS (non GAAP)$1.85 to $2.05same
Capital expenditures$245m to $265msame
Supply assumptionno change in the supply environment: stable availability and continued elevated product costssame

Management and CFO commentary

  • Valvoline files no separate CFO commentary document; management statements below come from the 8-K exhibits.
  • CEO Lori Flees, Q4 release (19 Nov 2026): 20th consecutive year of system wide SSS growth; system wide store sales above $4bn for the first time; the FY2027 outlook assumes no change in the supply environment, with stable availability and continued elevated product costs.
  • CEO Lori Flees, Q3 release (5 Aug 2026): increased finished lubricant costs to be mitigated with pricing actions and ongoing operational discipline; guidance ranges narrowed and SSS guidance raised.
  • Guidance revisions: SSS guidance moved from +4% to 6% (Nov 2025) to +5% to 6.5% (May 2026) and +7.5% to 8% (Aug 2026); actual +7.9%. Adjusted EPS guidance moved from $1.60 to $1.70 to $1.70 to $1.75; actual $1.76.
  • Investor update (11 Dec 2025): CEO Lori Flees, COO Linne Fulcher, Chief Franchising Officer Adam Worsham and CFO Kevin Willis presented the 2026 to 2028 financial model; the deck is filed as Ex 99.1.
Table 6.2 Management statements in their own words
SpeakerDate and sourceStatement
Lori Flees, President and CEO19 Nov 2026, 8-K Ex 99.1“Our outlook assumes no change in the supply environment”
Lori Flees, President and CEO5 Aug 2026, 8-K Ex 99.1“operating in a period of meaningful change on the cost side of our business”
Lori Flees, President and CEO1 Dec 2025, 8-K Ex 99.1“accelerates our growth by immediately increasing the number of stores within our network”
Table 6.3 Key disclosures in the Forms 10-K FY2025 and 10-Q FY2026
ItemDisclosure
10-Q Q3 FY2026, Breeze accountingCash consideration $637.4m; goodwill $524.3m after a $29.1m measurement period cut, mainly a $27.9m lower deferred tax liability; intangibles $19.0m over 10 years.
10-Q Q3 FY2026, Breeze divestiture45 stores with net assets of $90.0m sold on 1 Dec 2025 under the FTC order; pre tax loss $57.9m with no tax benefit; $6.3m of tax expense.
10-Q Q3 FY2026, pro formaWith Breeze from 1 Oct 2024: 9M FY2026 net revenues $1.54bn against $1.40bn; net income $158.6m against $90.5m.
10-Q Q3 FY2026, liquidityTotal debt $1.60bn at 30 Jun 2026; about 33% fixed rate; revolver capacity $470.1m; term loan B effective rate 5.393%; covenants met.
10-Q Q3 FY2026, capital allocationNo repurchases in 9M FY2026; $325.0m left under the 2024 authorization; repurchases paused to cut debt after Breeze; leverage target 1.5x to 2.5x.
10-Q Q3 FY2026, guaranteesLease guarantees on divested stores and Global Products up to $93.4m; franchisee debt guarantees $12.4m.
10-K FY2025, competitionNamed franchised competitors: Jiffy Lube, Grease Monkey, Take 5 Oil Change, Express Oil Change, Tire Engineers and Mr. Lube in Canada; dealerships and independents also compete.
10-K FY2025, workforceAbout 11,400 employees at 30 Sep 2025, 10,100 of them in company stores; the FY2026 release cites over 13,000 team members.
10-K FY2026Not on EDGAR on 19 Nov 2026.
Table 6.4 FY2026 guidance, every version, against the result
Measure19 Nov 20257 May 20265 Aug 2026FY2026 actual
System wide SSS growth4% to 6%5% to 6.5%7.5% to 8%7.9%
Store additions330 to 360no changeno change337
Net revenues$2.0bn to $2.1bnno change$2.05bn to $2.1bn$2.06bn
Adjusted EBITDA$525m to $550m$540m to $560m$550m to $560m$557m
Adjusted EPS$1.60 to $1.70$1.65 to $1.75$1.70 to $1.75$1.76
Capex$250m to $280mno change$240m to $260m$228m
Source: 8-K Ex 99.1 results releases. The release of 4 Feb 2026 carried no outlook table. The Nov 2025 outlook included Breeze.

7 Peer Valuation & Sector Summary

  • Peer set: Driven Brands (Take 5 Oil Change, the closest quick lube competitor, plus Meineke, Maaco and Auto Glass Now), Monro (full service tire and repair) and Mister Car Wash (car wash subscriptions). Periods differ: Valvoline FY2026 to Sep 2026, Monro TTM to Sep 2026, Mister Car Wash TTM to Mar 2026.
  • Growth, latest quarter year on year: Valvoline +22.1%, Mister Car Wash +6.2% (Mar 2026 quarter), Monro (1.8%) (Sep 2026 quarter). Driven Brands reported Q2 2026 revenue of $507.4m, +6.8%, in statements now under non reliance.
  • Margins: operating margin Mister Car Wash 19.3%, Valvoline 14.0% (FY2025 22.8%), Monro 1.7%; net margin Mister Car Wash 10.3%, Valvoline 4.3%, Monro 0.1%. Take 5 segment adjusted EBITDA was 34.3% of its Q2 2026 revenue against Valvoline's 25.9% adjusted EBITDA margin in Q4 FY2026; definitions differ.
  • Leverage: net debt Valvoline $1.45bn, Mister Car Wash $0.74bn (31 Mar 2026), Monro $85m excl. finance leases; Driven Brands reported net debt of about $1.4bn at 26 Sep 2026 (preliminary).
  • Valuation (18 Nov 2026 closes): Valvoline 48.4x TTM GAAP P/E and 2.8x EV/Sales; Monro 0.4x EV/Sales on $1.14bn of TTM sales; Driven Brands market value $1.81bn. Mister Car Wash holders received $7.00 per share in cash on 19 May 2026.
Table 7.1 Peer comparison, latest filed periods (see note for period ends)
CompanyRevenue TTM ($bn)Revenue growth (%)Gross margin (%)Operating margin (%)Net margin (%)FCF margin (%)ROE (%)Net cash ($bn)Market value ($bn)EV/Sales (x)P/E TTM (x)
VVV2.122.137.314.04.39.923.0(1.5)42.848.4
MNRO1.1(1.8)34.81.70.11.1n/a(0.1)00.4n/a
MCW1.16.2n/a19.310.3n/an/a(0.7)n/an/an/a
DRVNn/an/an/an/an/an/an/an/a2n/an/a
Valvoline: FY2026 to 30 Sep 2026, growth is Q4 FY2026 year on year, close 18 Nov 2026. Monro: TTM to 26 Sep 2026 (Q2 FY2027), growth is the Sep 2026 quarter, net cash excludes finance leases, close 18 Nov 2026; P/E not meaningful (TTM net income $0.8m). Mister Car Wash: TTM to 31 Mar 2026, its last filed quarter, net cash excludes finance leases; taken private at $7.00 per share on 19 May 2026, so no market value. Driven Brands: statements for FY2023 to FY2025 and Q1 and Q2 2026 under Item 4.02 non reliance (8-K of 3 Nov 2026) and Q3 2026 10-Q not filed, so only market value is shown (close 18 Nov 2026). Market values at 18 Nov 2026 closes: Valvoline $4.26bn, Monro $0.32bn, Driven Brands $1.81bn; the table rounds them to whole $bn. n/a: not available or not meaningful.
Figure 7.1 Revenue growth versus operating margin, peer set

8 Material Events & Contracts

  • 13 Forms 8-K between 20 Nov 2025 and 19 Nov 2026: four results releases, the Breeze closing, the investor update, three financings (Items 1.01 and 2.03, plus the notes offering under Item 8.01), four officer or director filings and the Item 5.07 vote results.
  • Breeze Autocare: closed 1 Dec 2025 for $637.4m in cash, funded with the $740m term loan B; 204 stores in California, Texas and the Midwest, 45 of them sold the same day; $16.7m of third party transaction costs in 9M FY2026 (10-Q).
  • Refinancing: term loan B repriced on 30 Jun 2026; $50m of term loan A prepaid in the Jun 2026 quarter; $600m of 6.125% notes due 2034 closed on 24 Aug 2026 and the revolver rose to $600m; total debt $1.61bn at 30 Sep 2026.
  • Leadership: CFO J. Kevin Willis since May 2025; Jordan Denny Chief Accounting Officer from Mar 2026; Katherine Fogertey and Scott Mezvinsky joined the board in Jul 2026.
Table 8.1 Forms 8-K filed between 20 Nov 2025 and 19 Nov 2026
DateItemsEvent
1 Dec 20251.01, 2.03, 8.01, 9.01Breeze Autocare acquisition closed; $740m term loan B at SOFR plus 2.00%, seven years; 45 Breeze stores sold to Main Street Auto Express Oil under the FTC order; net purchase price $593m before adjustments (Item 8.01; Ex 10.1 credit agreement, Ex 99.1 closing release). (0001674910-25-000136)
11 Dec 20257.01, 9.01Investor update: FY2026 to FY2028 targets of SSS +3% to 5%, net sales +9% to 11% a year, adjusted EBITDA margin +100 to 200 bps and leverage of 1.5x to 2.5x (about 3.2x pro forma after Breeze) (Ex 99.1). (0001674910-25-000140)
5 Jan 20265.02Former CFO Mary Meixelsperger retired on 29 Dec 2025. (0001674910-26-000002)
29 Jan 20265.02, 5.07Annual meeting of 28 Jan 2026: nine directors elected, Ernst & Young ratified, say on pay 87.8% and the 2026 Omnibus Incentive Plan 88.6% of votes cast. (0001674910-26-000006)
4 Feb 20262.02, 7.01, 9.01Q1 FY2026: net revenues $462m, +11%; SSS +5.8%; 200 net store additions incl. 162 Breeze stores; loss from continuing operations $32m after the divestiture loss (Ex 99.1). (0001674910-26-000010)
9 Mar 20265.02Jordan Denny appointed Chief Accounting Officer and Controller from 6 Mar 2026; base salary $319,520. (0001674910-26-000027)
7 May 20262.02, 7.01, 9.01Q2 FY2026: net revenues $504m, +25%; SSS +8.2%; adjusted EBITDA guide raised to $540m to $560m (Ex 99.1). (0001674910-26-000040)
30 Jun 20261.01, 2.03, 9.01Term loan B of $738.15m repriced to SOFR plus 1.75% from 2.00% (Ex 10.1). (0001674910-26-000049)
23 Jul 20265.02, 9.01Katherine Fogertey and Scott Mezvinsky elected to the board on 22 Jul 2026 (Ex 99.1). (0001674910-26-000052)
5 Aug 20262.02, 7.01, 9.01Q3 FY2026: net revenues $545m, +24%; SSS +8.0%; FY2026 SSS guide raised to 7.5% to 8%; $50m term loan A prepaid (Ex 99.1). (0001674910-26-000062)
13 Aug 20268.01, 9.01Senior notes due 2034 launched at $500m and priced at $600m and 6.125% (Ex 99.1, Ex 99.2). (0001674910-26-000071)
24 Aug 20261.01, 2.03, 9.01Notes closed; proceeds repay term loan A in full and part of term loan B; revolver raised to $600m from $475m for five years; leverage covenant 5.00x stepping to 4.75x and 4.50x (Ex 4.1, Ex 10.1). (0001628280-26-058633)
19 Nov 20262.02, 7.01, 9.01Q4 and FY2026 results and FY2027 outlook; repurchase authorization raised to $500m (Ex 99.1). (0001674910-26-000080)
Table 8.2 Material contracts and financing arrangements
ContractTerms
Breeze Autocare purchase (closed 1 Dec 2025)100% of OC IntermediateCo, Inc. from Greenbriar Equity Group under the agreement of 17 Feb 2025; cash consideration $637.4m (10-Q); 204 stores, 45 sold to Main Street Auto Express Oil under the FTC Decision and Order.
Second amended and restated credit agreement (Ex 10.1, 1 Dec 2025)$740m term loan B due 1 Dec 2032, SOFR plus 2.00%, repriced to SOFR plus 1.75% on 30 Jun 2026; maximum net leverage and minimum interest coverage covenants.
Amendment No. 2 (Ex 10.1, 24 Aug 2026)Revolver $600m (from $475m), five years, lower pricing; maximum net leverage 5.00x, 4.75x in year three and 4.50x in year four, plus 0.50x after a material acquisition.
6.125% senior notes due 2034 (Ex 4.1, 24 Aug 2026)$600m unsecured, due 15 Aug 2034, guaranteed by subsidiaries; proceeds repaid term loan A in full and part of term loan B. The 3.625% notes due 2031 ($535m) remain outstanding.
Supply agreement with VGOLong term purchase of substantially all lubricant and certain ancillary products from VGO (10-K FY2025).
Share repurchase authorization$400m authorization of Jul 2024 with $325.0m left at 30 Jun 2026; raised to $500m (Q4 release, 19 Nov 2026).

9 Ownership, Voting Power & Annual Meeting

  • One class of common stock: 127,586,418 shares outstanding at 30 Jul 2026 (10-Q cover). The proxy of 19 Dec 2025 lists The Vanguard Group 10.3%, BlackRock 9.6% and Wasatch Advisors 8.2%. In 2026 The Vanguard Group reported 0 shares (13G/A of 27 Mar 2026) and Vanguard Capital Management 5.26% (13G of 30 Apr 2026); Boston Partners reported 5.17% and Wasatch 4.8% at 30 Jun 2026.
  • Annual meeting of 28 Jan 2026 (8-K Item 5.07): 92.2% of shares represented; nine directors elected with 94.0% (Charles M. Sonsteby) to 96.5% (Chris Carr) of votes cast; say on pay 87.8%; 2026 Omnibus Incentive Plan 88.6%. CEO FY2025 total compensation $4.84m, a pay ratio of 118 to 1 (proxy).
  • Insiders, Forms 4 filed 20 Nov 2025 to 19 Nov 2026: open market purchases $0.95m by five insiders, incl. CFO Kevin Willis (20,000 shares in two purchases) and CEO Lori Flees (4,500 shares); sales $0.65m by two officers, $0.25m of it under Rule 10b5‑1 plans.
Table 9.1 Annual meeting vote results, 28 Jan 2026
ProposalFor (m votes)Against (m votes)Abstain (m votes)For as % of votes castResult
Elect Chris Carr106.93.90.296.5Elected
Elect Gerald W. Evans, Jr.105.75.10.395.4Elected
Elect Lori A. Flees106.93.90.296.5Elected
Elect Richard J. Freeland104.66.20.294.4Elected
Elect Carol H. Kruse104.66.20.294.4Elected
Elect Patrick S. Pacious106.74.10.296.3Elected
Elect Jennifer L. Slater106.93.90.296.4Elected
Elect Charles M. Sonsteby104.26.60.294.0Elected
Elect Janet S. Wong106.84.00.296.4Elected
Ratify Ernst & Young for FY2026116.40.70.299.4Ratified
Say on pay (advisory)97.213.50.487.8Approved
2026 Omnibus Incentive Plan98.112.60.388.6Approved
Broker non votes 6.24m on every item except the auditor ratification. Source: Form 8-K Items 5.02 and 5.07 of 29 Jan 2026 (linked in the Sources table).

Annual meeting remarks

  • No management remarks, presentation or shareholder questions from the meeting of 28 Jan 2026 were filed; the Item 5.07 filing reports vote counts only.
Table 9.2 Holders of 5% or more
HolderShares (m)Share of class (%)Basis
The Vanguard Group13.1210.3proxy (13G/A Feb 2024); 0 shares on 13G/A of 27 Mar 2026
BlackRock, Inc.12.269.6proxy (13G/A Jan 2024)
Vanguard Capital Management6.705.2613G of 30 Apr 2026 (31 Mar 2026)
Boston Partners6.605.1713G/A of 4 Aug 2026 (30 Jun 2026)
Wasatch Advisors LP6.074.813G/A of 17 Jul 2026 (30 Jun 2026); 8.2% in proxy
Proxy statement of 19 Dec 2025 (127,241,976 shares at 1 Dec 2025) and Schedules 13G and 13G/A filed in 2026.
Table 9.3 Open market purchases on Forms 4 filed 20 Nov 2025 to 19 Nov 2026
InsiderDateSharesPrice ($)Value ($m)
Lori Flees (President and CEO)24 Nov 20254,50030.820.139
Kevin Willis (CFO)21 Nov 202510,00031.410.314
Kevin Willis (CFO)14 May 202610,00031.800.318
Richard Freeland (director)14 May 20263,10032.370.100
Jennifer Slater (director)15 May 20261,00032.530.033
Jordan Denny (Chief Accounting Officer)12 Aug 20261,50633.200.050
Total $0.95m.
Table 9.4 Sales on Forms 4 filed 20 Nov 2025 to 19 Nov 2026 (code S)
InsiderDateSharesPrice ($)Value ($m)
Julie O'Daniel (Chief Legal Officer)26 Nov 20253,20031.880.102
Julie O'Daniel (Chief Legal Officer)20 Feb 20264,31238.550.166
Jonathan Caldwell (Chief People Officer)2 Mar 202698338.000.037 (10b5‑1)
Jonathan Caldwell (Chief People Officer)3 Mar 20262,67937.540.101 (10b5‑1)
Jonathan Caldwell (Chief People Officer)25 Jun 20262,85140.000.114 (10b5‑1)
Julie O'Daniel (Chief Legal Officer)21 Aug 20263,70033.810.125
Total $0.65m, of which $0.25m under Rule 10b5‑1 plans. Award grants, vesting and shares withheld for tax are excluded.

10 Risk Factors

  • Item 1A of the FY2025 Form 10-K holds 26 risk factors, the same count as a year earlier (8,098 words against 8,239): none added or removed and 6 materially reworded, incl. Breeze integration and tariffs. The three FY2026 Forms 10-Q report no material change. The FY2026 10-K, which will carry the next update, was not filed on 19 Nov 2026.
Table 10.1 Risk factors with filed figures
RiskDisclosure and change
Lubricant cost and supplySubstantially all lubricant comes from VGO; supply tightened in the Jun 2026 quarter; FY2026 gross margin 37.3% against 38.5%, Q4 35.3% against 39.1%; the FY2027 outlook assumes continued elevated product costs.
Debt and leverageTotal debt $1.61bn; net debt 2.6x adjusted EBITDA (report calculation) against a 1.5x to 2.5x target; covenant maximum 5.00x; net interest $113.5m in FY2026.
Acquisition integrationBreeze goodwill $524.3m, not tax deductible; conversion of Oil Changers stores to the VIOC brand named in the release; Breeze net income $13.1m from 1 Dec 2025 to 30 Jun 2026.
Franchisee performanceFranchised stores 1,252 of 2,517; franchised store sales $2.22bn; guarantees of $12.4m of franchisee debt and $93.4m of leases (10-Q).
Internal controls and ITMaterial weakness from the FY2024 ERP implementation; IT transition and remediation costs $19.3m in FY2026 (key item).
Vehicle technologyElectric vehicle adoption and longer service intervals are named in the release forward looking statements; the investor update names share of the hybrid car parc as a measure of success.
Legacy indemnitiesNet legacy and separation related expenses $25.8m in FY2026, $19.6m in Q4; indemnities run both to the former parent and from the Global Products buyer.
PensionEmployee benefit obligations $143.2m at 30 Sep 2026; Q4 net pension expense $16.7m from remeasurement.

How risk factors changed

  • Comparison: 10-K FY2025 filed 21 Nov 2025 against 10-K FY2024 filed 22 Nov 2024.
  • Same 26 risk factors in both years; total words 8,098 against 8,239.
  • Breeze integration enters the acquisition factor; tariffs enter the supply cost factor.
  • Global Products separation text shrinks as transition services end.
Figure 10.1 Risk factors by change against the prior filing
Table 10.2 Size of the risk factor section
Measure10-K FY202410-K FY2025
Risk factors (count)2626
Words in Item 1A8,2398,098
Table 10.3 Risk factors added, removed and materially reworded
ChangeRisk factorWhat changed
RewordedRising and volatile supply costsDrops the FY2024 air filter shortage and port strike examples; adds that new tariffs enacted in FY2025 had no material impact but future tariff changes could.
RewordedGrowth strategy and acquisitionsAdds integration risk for the then pending Breeze Autocare acquisition: synergies, management focus, internal controls, talent loss and customer attrition.
RewordedERP system and internal controlsStates ITGC deficiencies were remediated in FY2025 and that testing of business process controls to close the material weakness is expected in FY2026.
RewordedBusiness disruptions and catastrophic eventsRemoves the hurricane Beryl, Helene and Milton examples from FY2024.
RewordedBenefits of the Global Products saleRemoves the $2.383bn net proceeds and their use for buybacks and debt reduction.
RewordedDependence on VGORenames the supplier VGO and drops transition services, which ended; keeps dependence for substantially all lubricant and VGO indemnities.
Table 10.4 Risk factor updates in quarterly reports since the annual filing
FilingChange disclosed
10-Q Q1 FY2026 filed 4 Feb 2026No material change to the 10-K FY2025 risk factors.
10-Q Q2 FY2026 filed 7 May 2026No material change.
10-Q Q3 FY2026 filed 5 Aug 2026No material change.

11 Stock Price, Scenarios & Sensitivity

  • VVV closed at $33.37 on 18 Nov 2026, before the Q4 FY2026 release before the open on 19 Nov 2026; +6.6% on the Nov 2025 month end close of $31.31 and (2%) on Nov 2021. Highest month end close in five years $46.50 (Jul 2024); intraday range from 19 Nov 2025 to 18 Nov 2026 $26.21 to $41.08. On 19 Nov 2026 the shares traded as high as $38.00 intraday.
  • Valuation: market value $4.26bn on 127.59m shares (30 Jul 2026); enterprise value $5.71bn incl. net debt of $1.45bn; 48.4x FY2026 GAAP EPS, 19.0x adjusted EPS and 17.1x the FY2027 adjusted EPS guidance midpoint of $1.95; 10.2x FY2026 adjusted EBITDA of $557m; free cash flow yield 4.8%.
  • Scenario basis: GAAP P/E. Net revenues grow from FY2026 for three years to FY2029 at a GAAP operating margin (14.0% in FY2026, 22.8% in FY2025, 22.7% in FY2024). All inputs are this report's assumptions: pension, interest and financing costs $125m a year (FY2026 net interest $113.5m, Q4 $32.4m); tax rate 25% (FY2025 26.5%); shares 0% to 4% below 127.59m. FY2029 EPS times an exit P/E of 12x to 22x gives the implied price.
  • Price chart: monthly closes for five years, the last at 18 Nov 2026, followed by the best, base and worst case paths at the end of each of the next three years.
Figure 11.1 VVV monthly closing price and three year scenarios

Critical factors and core assumptions

Table 11.1 Critical factors behind the best case
FactorCurrent valueBest case requiresEvidence in filings
Same store sales+7.9% FY2026, +9.4% in Q4+5% to 7% held beyond FY2027FY2027 guide +5% to 7%; investor update +3% to 5% for 2026 to 2028
Store additions+337 in FY2026 incl. Breeze190 to 220 a year and more than 2,900 stores by 2028FY2027 guide; investor update of 11 Dec 2025
Gross margin and product cost37.3% FY2026, 35.3% in Q4pricing offsets lubricant inflation10-Q Q3 FY2026; FY2027 outlook assumes elevated costs
Breeze synergies$13.1m net income in seven monthsAUV up to about $1.2m after synergiesinvestor update: AUV $1.1m at acquisition, about $1.2m target, about 7.0x post synergy multiple
Leverage2.6x net debt to adjusted EBITDAunder 2.5x and repurchases resume$500m authorization; target 1.5x to 2.5x
One off costs$83.7m of divestiture loss and legacy costs in FY2026GAAP operating margin back above 20%FY2024 22.7%, FY2025 22.8% operating margin
  • Base year (filed): FY2026 net revenues $2.06bn, GAAP operating margin 14.0%; FY2027 guidance net revenues $2.25bn to $2.35bn and adjusted EPS $1.85 to $2.05.
  • Best case (report assumption): +11% net revenue CAGR, the top of the investor update range; 21.0% operating margin as one off costs fall away; 22x P/E; 4% fewer shares.
  • Base case (report assumption): +9% CAGR, the low end of the investor update range; 19.0% operating margin; 18x P/E; 2% fewer shares.
  • Worst case (report assumption): +4% CAGR on weaker SSS and fewer openings; 15.0% operating margin on sustained product cost pressure; 12x P/E; no change in shares.
  • All cases (report assumptions): pension, interest and financing costs $125m a year; tax rate 25%; EPS on shares outstanding (127.59m at 30 Jul 2026 less the assumed reduction); no dividends are paid.

Scenarios, three years forward

Table 11.2 Scenario analysis, FY2026 to FY2029
MeasureWorst caseBase caseBest case
Revenue CAGR, 3 years (%)4.09.011.0
Revenue, FY2029 ($bn)2.32.72.8
Operating margin, FY2029 (%)15.019.021.0
Net income, FY2029 ($bn)0.20.30.4
EPS, FY2029 ($)1.312.302.86
Exit P/E (x)12.018.022.0
Implied price ($)164163
Change against $33.37 (%)(53)2489
Implied annual return (%)(22.1)7.423.6
DescriptionProduct cost pressure and slower openingsLow end of the investor update rangeSSS and new stores at the top of targets
All scenario inputs are this report's assumptions, not company guidance. Operating margin is GAAP operating income over net revenues; EPS is net income over shares outstanding. Change measured against the close of 18 Nov 2026.
Figure 11.2 Three year price scenarios

Sensitivity analysis

Table 11.3 Sensitivity of implied price to revenue CAGR and operating margin at 18x P/E
Revenue CAGR \ Operating margin13%15%17%19%21%
3%$18$23$28$33$38
5%$20$25$30$36$41
7%$22$27$33$38$44
9%$24$30$36$41$47
11%$26$32$38$44$51
Cells show implied share price in year 3. Close 18 Nov 2026 $33.37. Blue cells sit above it, red cells below. FY2026 GAAP operating margin was 14.0%.
Table 11.4 Sensitivity of implied price to exit P/E and operating margin at 9% revenue CAGR
Exit P/E \ Operating margin13%15%17%19%21%
12x$16$20$24$28$31
15x$20$25$30$34$39
18x$24$30$36$41$47
21x$28$35$42$48$55
24x$32$40$47$55$63
Cells show implied share price in year 3. Close 18 Nov 2026 $33.37. Blue cells sit above it, red cells below. FY2026 GAAP operating margin was 14.0%.

Disclaimer

This analysis is for information only and is not financial advice. It is derived from public SEC filings retrieved via sec-api.io and is not a publication of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Scenario values are model outputs under stated assumptions and are not forecasts. Data as of 19 November 2026.

Sources

All company and peer figures are read from SEC filings retrieved through the sec-api.io MCP server. Peer figures come from each company's own Forms 8-K, 10-Q and 10-K. Share prices are regular session closes as dated in the text.

Table A.1 Filings used, with accession numbers
FormPeriodFiledAccession number
8-K Ex 99.130 Sep 202619 Nov 20260001674910-26-000080
10-Q30 Jun 20265 Aug 20260001674910-26-000066
10-Q31 Mar 20267 May 20260001674910-26-000045
10-Q31 Dec 20254 Feb 20260001674910-26-000015
10-K30 Sep 202521 Nov 20250001674910-25-000135
10-K30 Sep 202422 Nov 20240001674910-24-000152
8-K Ex 99.130 Jun 20265 Aug 20260001674910-26-000062
8-K Ex 99.131 Mar 20267 May 20260001674910-26-000040
8-K Ex 99.131 Dec 20254 Feb 20260001674910-26-000010
8-K Ex 99.130 Sep 202519 Nov 20250001674910-25-000133
8-K Ex 99.1 investor update11 Dec 20250001674910-25-000140
8-K Breeze closing, Ex 10.1, Ex 99.11 Dec 20250001674910-25-000136
8-K Ex 4.1, Ex 10.124 Aug 20260001628280-26-058633
8-K Ex 99.1, 99.213 Aug 20260001674910-26-000071
8-K Ex 10.130 Jun 20260001674910-26-000049
8-K Items 5.02, 5.0729 Jan 20260001674910-26-000006
DEF 14A19 Dec 20250001104659-25-122788
Schedule 13G/A Boston Partners30 Jun 20264 Aug 20260001386060-26-000039
Schedule 13G/A Wasatch30 Jun 202617 Jul 20260000814133-26-000103
Schedule 13G Vanguard Capital Management31 Mar 202630 Apr 20260002100119-26-001182
Schedule 13G/A Vanguard Group13 Mar 202627 Mar 20260000102909-26-002563
Table A.2 Peer filings used
CompanyFormFiledAccession number
Driven Brands8-K Ex 99.16 Aug 20260001804745-26-000072
Driven Brands10-Q6 Aug 20260001804745-26-000075
Driven Brands8-K Ex 99.13 Nov 20260001628280-26-069090
Mister Car Wash8-K Ex 99.118 Feb 20260001193125-26-056047
Mister Car Wash8-K Ex 99.129 Apr 20260001193125-26-191483
Mister Car Wash8-K Item 2.0119 May 20260001193125-26-229866
Monro10-K27 May 20260000876427-26-000007
Monro8-K Ex 99.129 Oct 20260001193125-26-437009
Monro10-Q29 Oct 20260000876427-26-000012
Table B.1 Exhibits to Forms 8-K filed in the last twelve months
FiledExhibitDocumentContent
1 Dec 2025Ex 10.1Incremental Amendment, Term Loan B$740m seven year senior secured term loan B at SOFR plus 2.00%; 0.25% quarterly amortization; proceeds fund Breeze and repay the revolver
1 Dec 2025Ex 99.1Breeze Autocare closing releaseBreeze Autocare bought from Greenbriar Equity Group under the agreement of 17 Feb 2025; CEO statement that the acquisition immediately increases the number of stores in the network; FTC divestiture and $593m net price are in Item 8.01 of the 8-K
11 Dec 2025Ex 99.1Investor update presentationFY2026 to FY2028: SSS +3% to 5%, net sales +9% to 11%, adjusted EBITDA margin +100 to 200 bps; Leverage target 1.5x to 2.5x; about 3.2x pro forma after Breeze; more than 2,900 stores by 2028
4 Feb 2026Ex 99.1Q1 FY2026 resultsNet revenues $462m, +11%; SSS +5.8%; 200 net store additions incl. 162 Breeze stores; Loss from continuing operations $32m after the FTC required divestiture
7 May 2026Ex 99.1Q2 FY2026 resultsNet revenues $504m, +25%; SSS +8.2%; adjusted EBITDA $134m, +28%; FY2026 adjusted EBITDA guide raised to $540m to $560m
30 Jun 2026Ex 10.1Amendment No. 1, Term Loan B repricing$738.15m term loan B repriced to SOFR plus 1.75% from 2.00%; Maturity unchanged at seven years after 1 Dec 2025
23 Jul 2026Ex 99.1Board appointments releaseKatherine Fogertey and Scott Mezvinsky elected to the board on 22 Jul 2026; Prorated restricted stock units of $70,644 each
5 Aug 2026Ex 99.1Q3 FY2026 resultsNet revenues $545m, +24%; SSS +8.0%; adjusted EBITDA $162m, +25%; FY2026 SSS guide raised to 7.5% to 8%; $50m term loan A prepayment
13 Aug 2026Ex 99.1Notes offering launch$500m senior notes due 2034 offered; Proceeds to repay term loan A and part of term loan B
13 Aug 2026Ex 99.2Notes offering pricingUpsized to $600m at 6.125% due 2034
24 Aug 2026Ex 4.1Indenture, 6.125% notes due 2034$600m unsecured notes due 15 Aug 2034, guaranteed by subsidiaries
24 Aug 2026Ex 10.1Amendment No. 2, credit agreementRevolver raised to $600m from $475m, five years, lower pricing; Maximum net leverage 5.00x, stepping to 4.75x and 4.50x in years three and four
19 Nov 2026Ex 99.1Q4 and FY2026 resultsFY2026 net revenues $2.06bn, +21%; system wide store sales $4.07bn, +18%; SSS +7.9%; FY2027 guide: net revenues $2.25bn to $2.35bn, adjusted EPS $1.85 to $2.05; repurchase authorization raised to $500m